When a composite pressure vessel fails, one side often alleges a manufacturing defect and the other points to damage or misuse. Both can be true, and neither is proven by the failure itself. A manufacturing defect means the vessel was not built the way its approved design and the governing standard required. Showing that, or ruling it out, takes four kinds of evidence.
1. The approved design and its standard
Start with what the vessel was supposed to be: the design qualification report, the approval or special permit, the drawings and the material and process specifications behind them. These set the benchmark for every later comparison: fiber and resin type, laminate thickness and layup, liner and boss design, cure cycle, and the qualification test results the design achieved.
2. The production record for that vessel and its lot
Composite cylinders are built and tested in lots. The serial number on the label leads to the lot's records: material certificates for the fiber, resin and liner, winding program and machine logs, cure records, hydrostatic test results and the lot tests themselves. Under DOT-CFFC, FRP-1 and ISO 11119-2, for example, a cylinder from each lot of up to 200 is burst-tested and another is pressure-cycled. The independent inspection agency's reports show what was witnessed. Gaps, retests or out-of-tolerance results in those records are often the first real lead.
3. The failed vessel itself
The fracture surfaces show where the failure started and how it ran. Sections cut through the laminate, under a protocol agreed by all parties, show fiber alignment, wrinkles, voids and resin distribution. Laboratory tests can confirm whether the resin was fully cured and whether the materials match the specification. CT scanning can show liner condition and internal features before anything is cut.
4. Exemplars from the same lot
An intact vessel from the same production lot is the best reference there is. Burst-testing or sectioning exemplars shows whether the failed vessel was an outlier or typical of its lot, which goes straight to whether a defect was isolated or systemic. Preserve them early: lots are used up, sold and retired.
Separating defect from damage and use
The same examination has to test the alternatives. Impact, cuts and abrasion leave their own marks on the overwrap. Chemical exposure, heat and fire change the resin. Overpressure, overfilling or use past the vessel's service life point away from manufacturing. A credible opinion explains why the evidence fits one cause and not the others.
Investigating a cylinder failure?
Contact us before any destructive examination or testing. We can help agree an inspection protocol, preserve the evidence and scope the failure analysis.
This is general technical guidance, not legal advice. Every matter depends on its own facts and evidence.