ARAGNA TECHExperience. Integrity. Clarity.

Insights · Failure investigation

What to preserve after a composite cylinder failure

The first 48 hours after a cylinder rupture or leak decide what can be proven later. Six steps for counsel, insurers and operators to protect the evidence for every party.

Shaun Hogan & Alexis Dubois, PhD · November 2026 · 4 min read

Most disputes over a failed cylinder are decided by evidence that was moved, cleaned or tested before all parties had a chance to see it. The steps below protect the facts for everyone, whichever side you are on.

1. Do not section, clean or test anything yet

Destructive work done by one party, even with good intentions, invites spoliation disputes. Fracture surfaces in particular carry the record of how the cylinder failed, and they are easily damaged by handling or cleaning.

2. Secure the fragments, the valve and the mounting hardware

Collect every piece you safely can, including the valve, regulator, fittings, brackets and straps. Bag and label them separately, note where each was found, and keep them dry.

3. Collect the records

Fill logs, inspection and requalification records, maintenance and overhaul records, purchase records and the cylinder label details. These often answer the first questions: who made the cylinder, to which rules, and whether it was within its service life.

4. Photograph the scene before anything is moved

Wide shots, then close-ups of every fragment in place, the label and markings, and the surrounding area. Record the time and who took each photo.

5. Agree a joint inspection protocol

Before any examination, agree with all parties who attends, what is done, in which order and with what methods. ASTM E860 and ASTM E1188 describe accepted practices for handling items that are, or may become, involved in litigation. In a fire, NFPA 921 governs the scene investigation.

6. Bring in a pressure vessel expert before the first inspection

The protocol should be written with someone who knows how these cylinders are built and how they fail, so the right samples are taken the first time.

This is general guidance, not legal advice. Your counsel decides how evidence is preserved in a specific matter.