Expert witness · Oxygen systems
Oxygen cylinder, valve & regulator expert witness.
Independent technical analysis of high-pressure oxygen cylinders, valves and regulators for product liability and accident litigation, including aviation emergency oxygen, medical oxygen and industrial gas cylinders. For plaintiff and defense counsel.
What we examine
The cylinder, the valve and the record behind them.
Oxygen cases turn on a few hard facts: who made the cylinder and to which rules, whether it was in service life and properly requalified, whether the valve and regulator materials were compatible with oxygen, and whether the system was clean.
Oxygen cylinders
Composite and metal cylinders: the specification or DOT special permit they were built to, damage, service life and whether the cylinder should still have been in service.
Valves & regulators
Seat, seal and lubricant materials against oxygen compatibility standards, and the design features that limit ignition risk in high-pressure oxygen.
Oxygen-service cleanliness
Cleaning specifications, contamination and the cleaning record after manufacture, overhaul or repair.
Overhaul & requalification
Hydrostatic retest and inspection history, requalifier marks, maintenance records and service-life limits.
Labels & markings
Identifying the actual cylinder manufacturer and the permit or specification it was made under, often the quickest fact to settle.
Regulatory framework
DOT rules under 49 CFR Parts 173, 178 and 180, DOT special permits, FAA rules under 14 CFR, and ISO 11114 and ASTM oxygen compatibility standards.
Oxygen-service standards we work to
49 CFR Parts 171 to 180, including §173.302 for filling cylinders with compressed gas and §175.501 for air transport of oxygen; Federal Specification RR-C-901; CGA G-4.1 and G-4.4; ASTM G88, G93 and G94; and ISO 11114 for oxygen compatibility of metals, seals, valve seats and lubricants.
What we do not do
We are pressure vessel and component experts, not fire origin and cause investigators. In fire cases, origin and cause should be determined by a certified fire investigator working to NFPA 921. We address the cylinder, valve and regulator questions alongside that investigator.
Our experience
Engineers who built these cylinders.
Shaun Hogan spent 40+ years designing, qualifying and building composite pressure vessels. As Vice President of Engineering at EFI Corporation he led engineering and quality for more than 250,000 Type 3 breathing cylinders, and he managed engineering of composite cylinders for Boeing, Airbus and Canadair aircraft, emergency oxygen among them.
Alexis Dubois, PhD works on high-pressure gas safety and forensics, including failure analysis of Type 4 CNG and SCBA cylinders, and the DOT and ISO rules that govern how cylinders are made, filled and requalified.
Questions
For counsel and insurers.
Matters are accepted after a conflict check. CVs, fee schedule and testimony history are available on request.
Who should we retain for an oxygen cylinder or regulator failure?
An engineer who has designed, qualified and built high-pressure cylinders and knows the rules they are made and requalified under. Our principals cover the cylinder, valve and regulator, oxygen-service cleanliness, and the overhaul and requalification history.
Which regulations apply to an aircraft oxygen cylinder?
Two sets at once. The FAA rules under 14 CFR cover the oxygen system as installed on the aircraft. The cylinder itself is a DOT pressure vessel: it is made to a DOT specification or special permit and filled and requalified under 49 CFR Parts 173, 178 and 180. Oxygen compatibility of valve and regulator materials is addressed by standards such as ISO 11114 and ASTM G63 and G94. See our overview of aviation oxygen cylinder regulations.
Do you determine fire origin and cause?
No. Origin and cause should be determined by a certified fire investigator working to NFPA 921. We address the cylinder, valve and regulator questions alongside the investigator retained for origin and cause.
How early should we involve you?
Before anyone handles, cleans or tests the cylinder, valve or regulator. An agreed joint inspection protocol protects the evidence for every party.